Memphis has recently publicized 2 major initiatives with huge real estate angles,
Triangle Noir and the
Parks Services Master Plan.
As these move forward, backward, sideways, into the shadows, under the cone of silence and back through the echo chamber, we must ask hard questions of
everyone -- the public officials, the businesspeople, the citizens ---
not just the politicians! -- involved with them.
For instance, re: the Parks Services Master Plan:
- Who's on the committee?
- What's the proportion of citizen representation to business representation?
- How much of that is developer representation?
- Do any of the representatives have contracts with the city?
- Do any of the representatives have relatives who work for the city?
- Do any of the representatives have private dealings with the Mayor?
- Are any possible divestitures in the vicinity of major city led developments, e.g., Uptown, Fairgrounds, etc.
or for Triangle Noir:
- Why is it necessary to remove anybody from the Triangle Noir? Isn't there enough space to infill?
- Hasnt' the public housing being recently renovated? How is it dilapidated?
- How does this improve Memphis outside of Downtown?
- How will we pay for the elderly housing required in the rest of the city?
- Are there enough Section 8 vouchers available to everyone scattered by Triangle Noir?
- Will eminent domain be used?
- If so, will takings be given to private developers?
- Are any of the possible developers on the Mayor's host committee?
- Who owns property in the Triangle now?
- What are their connections to city government?
- What will Triangle Noir do to the mix of income in downtown Memphis?
I don't believe the questions are cynical. They're just the type of questions that should be asked anywhere the public realm is opened to exclusive private uses. Vigilantly asked by citizens and the press, and reasonably answered by independent means, they're an antidote to cynicism.
Public-private partnerships promise revenue and/or efficiency, but they will eviscerate the public realm, subvert public power to private ends and corrupt our democracy unless we ask and get answers.
Labels: downtown, Memphis, Memphis Parks, urban planning